Latest Coverage
See all articles
OTHERS SAY: Colleges need a refresher on free speech
At Republicans' recent midterm convention, Rep. Brandon Gill (R-Texas) began his remarks with his own version of a land acknowledgment.
"I'd like to acknowledge that we stand here today in the great state of Texas and the United States of America is the ancestral homeland of great American patriots, pioneers and explorers who put down roots, fight for freedom all over the globe, and bled and died to build the greatest civilization ever known to man," Gill said.
The crowd roared its approval for Gill's parody. But if he had been working at a taxpayer-funded university, he likely would have received a different response. Just ask Professor Stuart Reges.
Reges is a computer science professor at the University of Washington, a publicly funded institution. A few years ago, the school encouraged professors to put indigenous land acknowledgments in their course syllabi.
Reges wasn't interested in following the herd. Instead of simply ignoring the directive, in 2022 he published a parody of what UW had in mind. University bigwigs weren't amused. The school launched an investigation. It censored his syllabus and apologized to his students. The school even created a different version of his class, so students didn't have to learn from him.
The university's reaction would be funny--in response to a parody, UW turned into a parody version of a woke college--if the issue weren't so serious. Universities once prided themselves on defending free speech. Now, many crack down on any who dare to deviate from progressive orthodoxy. There isn't a market for this foolishness, but colleges receive substantial subsidies from taxpayers.
With the help of the Foundation for Individual Rights and Expression, Reges sued. Instead of apologizing, UW contested the issue.
Fortunately, after a years-long court battle, the Ninth Circuit upheld Reges' First Amendment rights. UW recently agreed to pay him $600,000 for its actions, although it still won't acknowledge that it did anything wrong.
Public universities should skip land acknowledgments and make sure that administrators acknowledge the Constitution.